Marcel Winatschek

Still Smiling

Three young women in Kabul want what anyone wants—to study, play music, have a future. Watching the documentary about them, the first thing that hits you is how much they smile. Sadaf, Sahar, and Nargis are driving through the city, practicing drums, attending protests, and they’re constantly grinning. The camera doesn’t flinch from what’s happening around them—bombs, harassment, women disappearing—it just holds both at the same time. The laughter and the darkness, coexisting.

They’re not symbols or abstractions. Sahar studies, Nargis plays drums, Sadaf does her own thing. They get harassed constantly for the basic crime of being visible young women with opinions. They show up to feminist protests and hand out flyers about violence against women. In Kabul, this is genuinely dangerous work, and the film treats it that way—not as inspiration, just as fact.

What strikes me watching is how little they seem to be performing for the camera. They’re not building some noble narrative of resistance. They’re just refusing to stop being young, to stop taking up space, to stop making noise. And the documentary gets this: what they’re doing isn’t triumphant or tragic. It’s just what it looks like to choose yourself when that choice costs everything.

The film doesn’t resolve anything. It ends with them still there, still driving, still refusing, the problems still waiting. You finish watching and the weight doesn’t leave you. The way it shouldn’t.