Marcel Winatschek

Chaos as a Considered Position

The tracklist alone is a statement: "Blow My Load," "Deathcamp," "Fucking Young." Tyler, the Creator names his songs the way someone who’s read too much and been told no too rarely would name anything, which is either insufferable or exactly right depending on the day.

Cherry Bomb dropped in April 2015 with the same studied refusal to behave that’s defined Tyler since the Odd Future days. I’d been calling him the new Pharrell for a while—not as compliment or insult, just pattern recognition: the same restless genre-collapse, the same willingness to be cheerful and disturbing in the same breath. But where Pharrell eventually settled into pure luxury, Tyler keeps one foot deliberately in the mud. He’s committed to the difficult on principle.

The album sounds like a controlled mess, which is the hardest thing to pull off. Guitars go strange. Drums land slightly wrong. Melodies surface and disappear before you can hold onto them. It took three listens before it stopped feeling like a mistake and started feeling like a series of decisions—which is the Tyler experience in general. You think you’re watching someone flail, and then you realize the flailing is the point.

"Fucking Young" is one of the better things he’s made—that piano line, the restraint in the delivery, the way something genuinely romantic manages to survive under all the provocateur framing. Cherry Bomb has more feeling in it than the chaos suggests. The title might be adolescent. The record isn’t.