Marcel Winatschek

The Scam Finds Its Medium

Fake news didn’t start as a political problem—it started as an advertising model. Someone figures out that a story formatted to look like a major outlet, placed where people are already in a trusting, scrolling state of mind, will get clicks. Clicks become ad revenue. The content doesn’t have to be true. It doesn’t even have to be plausible. "iPhone for €17." "How one obscure trick made investors millionaires." "Lose 12 kilos in 30 days." The more outrageous, the better the click-through rate—and the operators running these things, typically sitting in jurisdictions where takedowns are difficult and accountability is theoretical, were reportedly pulling six-figure monthly revenues from content that cost almost nothing to produce.

The companion scam is slightly more brazen: legitimate-looking display ads placed on otherwise reputable platforms that funnel you somewhere genuinely dark the moment you click. Publishers accepted these because the money was good and the due diligence required to screen them out wasn’t. That calculation hasn’t fully changed.

Neither of these things is new—spam email ran the same playbook for twenty years before social networks scaled it up. What changed was the delivery mechanism: a platform engineered to keep you scrolling, in a semi-hypnotic state, with your critical faculties at low idle. The con is the same one it’s always been. The conditions for running it have never been better.